Pilot #1 Active · Cosmo Crew (Weeks 5–8 of 13)

Interactive 90-Day Pilot Board & IP Scorecard Comparator

Success Criteria: One validated product signal (Luna Rhythm game start-rate ≥10% or Luna plush waitlist ≥4%) plus a documented reusable Playbook entry.

9 Validation Gates 4-IP Scorecard Comparator Evidence-Only Copilot

13-Week Validation Governance

Pilot #1 — Cosmo Crew 9-Gate Progression Board

Budget: $48,000 · Used: $19,200 (40%) · Decision Maker: Elena Varga

Weeks 1–2 PASSED · GO

Gate 1 — Concept Validation

Music-led IP with four characters and The Quiet Ship.

Gate Owner: Elena Varga

Weeks 1–2 PASSED · GO

Gate 2 — Audience Signal

428k audience; Luna music episodes measured at +42% repeat viewing.

Gate Owner: Elena Varga

Weeks 3–4 IN PROGRESS · PENDING

Gate 3 — Prototype

5-minute browser rhythm game prototype (Luna Rhythm) in build; account-free & COPPA-conscious.

Gate Owner: Jules Okonkwo

Weeks 5–8 IN PROGRESS · PENDING

Gate 4 — MVP

Landing page + playable prototype linked from two Luna video end cards (Target: ≥10% start-game rate).

Gate Owner: Jules Okonkwo

Weeks 9–10 PENDING · PENDING

Gate 5 — Paying Customer

Luna crescent plush song-led waitlist test (Target: ≥4% conversion) before any inventory.

Gate Owner: Elena Varga

Weeks 11–12 PENDING · PENDING

Gate 6 — Repeat Engagement

Measure repeat plays on Night Song interactive level.

Gate Owner: Mara Chen

Weeks 11–12 PENDING · PENDING

Gate 7 — Product-Market Signal

One validated product signal + documented playbook entry.

Gate Owner: Elena Varga

Week 13 PENDING · PENDING

Gate 8 — IP Expansion

Reuse rhythm engine for Jungle Jams (Kiko Karaoke).

Gate Owner: Jules Okonkwo

Week 13 PENDING · PENDING

Gate 9 — Licensing / Retail

Harbor & Pine Publishing picture-book deal review.

Gate Owner: Elena Varga

11-Factor Commercialization Matrix

Interactive IP Scorecard Comparator

Select an IP below to inspect its 11 factor scores (Human vs AI-assisted) and evidence notes.

IP Property	Category & Audience	Stage	Human Score	AI Score	Primary Measured Signal
Cosmo Crew	Kids entertainment (Ages 4–8) 428,000 subscribers · 18.4M trailing views	Experiments (Weeks 5–8)	82/100	79/100	Music episodes featuring Luna generate +42% higher repeat viewing than the channel average.
Jungle Jams	Music (Ages 3–7) 190,000 subscribers	Signals	71/100	73/100	Kiko Counts the Rain achieves 64% retention (+13 pts vs channel average). Candidate for engine reuse.
Monster Melody Club	Comedy-Music (Ages 5–9) 312,000 subscribers	Audience	68/100	70/100	High licensing appeal: Porchlight Venues Co. birthday-hour license prospect ($80k deal value).
Tiny Inventors	STEM Education (Ages 6–10) 95,000 subscribers	Opportunities	64/100	66/100	High save-rate on build episodes; 11,000-member segment pausing videos to copy builds.

Cosmo Crew — 11-Dimension Scorecard Breakdown

Creative: Mara Chen · Tech: Jules Okonkwo · Business: Elena Varga

Human Total: 82 AI Total: 79

Existing Audience Traction (w=15)

Human: 9/10 AI: 8/10

428k subs, 18.4M trailing views

Audience Engagement (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

41% returning viewer rate on music episodes

Character / IP Strength (w=10)

Human: 9/10 AI: 8/10

Luna dominates comments and costume requests

World Expansion Potential (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 7/10

Quiet Ship + 4 crew, expandable constellations

Content Scalability (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

Song format is highly repeatable

Digital Product Potential (w=10)

Human: 9/10 AI: 8/10

Luna Rhythm browser prototype in flight

AI / Interactive Potential (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 9/10

Character bibles have strict safety boundaries

90-Day Monetization (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 7/10

Landing page + waitlist test active

Physical Product Potential (w=5)

Human: 7/10 AI: 7/10

Luna crescent plush requests +62%

Licensing / Partnership (w=5)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Harbor & Pine picture-book discussion ($120k)

Measurement Quality (w=5)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

CSV imports + tagged catalog

Jungle Jams — 11-Dimension Scorecard Breakdown

Creative: Diego Alvarez · Tech: Jules Okonkwo · Business: Elena Varga

Human Total: 71 AI Total: 73

Existing Audience Traction (w=15)

Human: 7/10 AI: 7/10

190k subs, steady organic growth

Audience Engagement (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

Call-and-response retention is excellent

Character / IP Strength (w=10)

Human: 7/10 AI: 8/10

Kiko is strong; chorus less distinct

World Expansion Potential (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

Habitat model is a franchise engine

Content Scalability (w=10)

Human: 7/10 AI: 7/10

Need more episode templates

Digital Product Potential (w=10)

Human: 7/10 AI: 7/10

Kiko Karaoke reuses Cosmo rhythm engine

AI / Interactive Potential (w=10)

Human: 6/10 AI: 7/10

World rules exist; voice specs maturing

90-Day Monetization (w=10)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

One album live; product test queued after Cosmo

Physical Product Potential (w=5)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Plush chorus possible

Licensing / Partnership (w=5)

Human: 6/10 AI: 7/10

Conservation & music education alignment

Measurement Quality (w=5)

Human: 7/10 AI: 7/10

Good view data, thin comment tagging

Monster Melody Club — 11-Dimension Scorecard Breakdown

Creative: Samira Haddad · Tech: Jules Okonkwo · Business: Elena Varga

Human Total: 68 AI Total: 70

Existing Audience Traction (w=15)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

312k subs, bursty growth

Audience Engagement (w=10)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

High views, lower repeat rate than Cosmo

Character / IP Strength (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

Glimmer is highly quotable and licensable

World Expansion Potential (w=10)

Human: 7/10 AI: 7/10

Guest-monster variety engine

Content Scalability (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

Variety-show format scales cleanly

Digital Product Potential (w=10)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Less obvious interactive game hook

AI / Interactive Potential (w=10)

Human: 6/10 AI: 7/10

Host character is AI-ready

90-Day Monetization (w=10)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Venue licensing cycle slower than digital test

Physical Product Potential (w=5)

Human: 7/10 AI: 7/10

Plushes and party kits

Licensing / Partnership (w=5)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

Strong live events and venue fit

Measurement Quality (w=5)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Needs product-intent tagging

Tiny Inventors — 11-Dimension Scorecard Breakdown

Creative: Priya Shah · Tech: Jules Okonkwo · Business: Elena Varga

Human Total: 64 AI Total: 66

Existing Audience Traction (w=15)

Human: 5/10 AI: 5/10

95k subs, newer property

Audience Engagement (w=10)

Human: 7/10 AI: 7/10

High save-rate on build episodes

Character / IP Strength (w=10)

Human: 7/10 AI: 6/10

Mei is clear; supporting cast maturing

World Expansion Potential (w=10)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Expansion is craft kits & printables

Content Scalability (w=10)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Build episodes take longer to produce

Digital Product Potential (w=10)

Human: 8/10 AI: 8/10

Printable build cards and app kits

AI / Interactive Potential (w=10)

Human: 7/10 AI: 8/10

Constrained safe making-assistant fit

90-Day Monetization (w=10)

Human: 5/10 AI: 5/10

Free PDFs currently; paid kit test queued

Physical Product Potential (w=5)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Cardboard/wood craft kits

Licensing / Partnership (w=5)

Human: 5/10 AI: 6/10

Ed-tech & homeschool channels

Measurement Quality (w=5)

Human: 6/10 AI: 6/10

Need product-intent tagging

Evidence-Only Studio Copilot

Structured Decision Record: Why Cosmo Crew Was Selected First

Measured Fact

Cosmo Crew has the highest human commercialization score (82/100) and 428k subscribers across 18.4M trailing views.

Audience Signal

Music episodes featuring Luna generate +42% repeat viewing; Luna merch comments are +62% vs non-Luna videos.

AI Inference

A 5-minute browser rhythm game prototype (Luna Rhythm) is the fastest path to a ≥10% product-interest metric within 90 days.

Human Judgment

Keep prototype account-free for COPPA safety; validate plush demand via waitlist before committing inventory capital.